How the Calculator Works
LLC scenario: SE tax is computed on 92.35% of net income. The 50% SE deduction reduces AGI. If QBI-eligible, 20% of (net income minus SE deduction) is deducted, limited to 20% of taxable income before the deduction. Above the 2026 threshold ($201,750 single / $403,500 MFJ) the deduction phases down over the next $75,000 / $150,000 of taxable income toward the W-2 wage limit; the calculator assumes the LLC has no employees and no qualified property, so a fully phased-in LLC keeps only the $400 minimum deduction (IRC §199A(i)). 2026 federal income tax brackets are then applied.
S-Corp scenario: The owner pays FICA (15.3%) only on the reasonable salary. The employer's share (7.65%) is deductible at the entity level, reducing the K-1 distribution. If QBI-eligible, 20% of distributions is deducted (W-2 salary does not qualify for QBI), limited to 20% of taxable income. Above the threshold, the limit is phased in toward 50% of the W-2 wages the S-Corp pays, which here is your salary (IRC §199A(b)(2) and (b)(3)). Income tax brackets are applied to salary plus distribution.
Compliance cost is added to the S-Corp total cost (not to taxes) to show the true economic comparison. The default is $3,000/year. Adjust to match your actual payroll processing and Form 1120S preparation fees.
Breakeven: The S-Corp wins when gross SE tax savings exceed annual compliance cost. At $3,000 overhead and a 15.3% SE rate, the distribution above salary must exceed approximately $21,300 before the S-Corp saves money net of costs.
To understand the LLC baseline, see our Self-Employment Tax Guide and the 1099 Tax Calculator. For a full explanation of the S-Corp election mechanism, reasonable salary requirements, compliance costs, and the breakeven analysis, see the LLC vs S-Corp Guide.